Why is discernment less welcome in the church? Where and how can I use it? Spiritual Gifts FAQs

Question:

Why is discernment less welcome in the church? Where and how can I use it? Spiritual Gifts FAQs

 

Reply:

You might also reference: Spiritual Gifts FAQs #9 Q: How do I use my spiritual gifts of Discernment and Prophecy appropriately, especially in the church? It feels like there is less appreciation for or welcoming of these gifts.

 

Unfortunately this is not an uncommon question and experience for those with the Gift of Discernment in the Church. I think there are a number of factors why the lack of welcome or appreciation of this gift might be true. I also exhort you and others to continue to pray for this to change.

 

1. The “downside” of the Gift of Discernment is that it can sound like judgment or feel like accountability—neither of which are typically welcomed by church leaders. How the message is delivered makes a difference. Asking yourself “what is my motivation in sharing this?”, “am I communicating this in love”, “what do I hope to accomplish in saying what I believe the Lord is leading me to say” can be helpful. Backing up a step, before sharing anything, praying for the Lord to confirm whether He is making you aware so you can pray and prepare for something future or whether He is making you aware so you can say something to bring about needed change is crucial. It is messy to submit to the Lord and to one another as we attempt to become a healthy, flourishing Body of Christ together—respecting and using ALL of the gifts, dismissing none of them.

 

2. A leader’s ego can get in the way of hearing Discernment, even well-delivered. Not all church leaders see themselves nor operate as servant leaders or shepherds of the “flock” entrusted to them. Perhaps the underlying issue is that church leadership is more committed to their jobs or success instead of to Jesus, His Church, and His kingdom? Or is it perhaps that the dedication of the leader/s in question is less about love, compassion, mercy, reconciliation, forgiveness, integrity, honesty, humility and care for others…and more about personal gain? Remember, Jesus warned leaders of his day—religious leaders in particular—of their ungodly and power-motivated tendencies toward hypocrisy, unreasonable demands placed upon their human flocks, lack of empathy toward those they lead, pride, and narcissism. Any and all of these can cause a leader to ignore or wish to dismiss Discernment—especially if it is “on point.” [See also Abuse of Power in the Church—Part III—Jesus Has Something to Say to Leaders.]

 

3. Keep in mind that the message you are trying to communicate also comes in with all the other “noise” that church leaders are subject to…and can sound like “just another” complaint.

 

4. Oftentimes, the Gift of Discernment gives you a sense that something is “not quite right” or “something is off”—but it’s difficult initially to exactly put your finger on it or even to articulate it. However, the new direction/ministry idea/vision/next step looks and sounds “right” to others, leaving you looking more like the rain on their parade. We have, in the Church, dismissed these “early warnings” all too often, to our peril.

 

5. The gift and our own maturity are always growing and developing (or should be): “While ultimately a gift from God, discernment doesn't simply fall into our laps in a mature form…Discernment is something we should actively seek to develop and ask God to increase in our lives as we create the conditions for him to do so. This gift can only be cultivated in a spirit of humility and the fear of the Lord, and a heart that is practised in the spiritual disciplines of prayer, meditating on Scripture, confession, and silence.” (from a Lectio 365 app devotion)

 

Reflect:

·         How can you use your Gift of Discernment for the healing and protection of the church or group of which you are a member?

·         How can you ensure that your messaging is done in love?

·         Where are you still using this gift even in what might appear to be the “background”—every time you read Scripture, listen to the news, participate in a small group, read a book, hear a sermon, etc. for the betterment of others?

Important resources:

 

 

Shirley Giles Davis, author of God's Affirmations For You: A Book of Encouragement—A 12-Week Devotional Practice , the God. Gifts. You. Your Unique Calling and Design workbook, Your Unique Design Class Guide , Your Unique Design Facilitator Guide , DIOS. GIFTS. YOU: Your Calling and Unique Design (Spanish Edition) , and Gifts-Calling-Purpose blog , is a consultant, coach, facilitator who has worked with hundreds of faith-based organizations, nonprofit agencies, and executive leaders in a diversity of fields for four decades. She currently serves as Catalyst for Equipping at her church.

Photo © Shirley Giles Davis. 

All rights reserved.

Additionally, the contents of these blog posts may not be used to train generative artificial intelligence (AI) technologies without the author's express permission.

Shirley Giles Davis